Saturday, August 22, 2009

Two or Three Degrees - What Could Happen?

Did you know that in the last million years the global temperature has not been more than 1 degree Centigrade hotter than it is now? In an earlier blog I listed some of the things that could happen if the global temperature reached one degree higher, but as my previous post noted, it seems guaranteed to get at least a degree or two hotter than that. What will this mean, what changes can we expect?

Here is a list of predictions if global temperatures go 1 - 2 degrees above 2008 global temperatures, or about 1.7 - 2.7 degrees C above preindustrial levels. These come from the book and DVD “Six Degrees”, by Mark Lynas and National Geographic, respectively. These are all predictions made by scientists, either based on what we know of the past (paleoclimatology) or on models of the future. Things could turn out better or worse than these predictions indicate, but this is the best and most complete list that I’m aware of.

-We will be on the brink of runaway global warming – many think this will be the tipping point, when feedback could take over.
-The tundra in the North will almost totally disappear, and the permafrost boundary will move hundreds of miles north.
-We will lose the vast majority of coral reefs and the millions of species that depend on them.
-The oceans will be too acidic for the formation of shells, imperiling shellfish, plankton, and most other life in the oceans (since the food chain depends on plankton).
-Over a third of all species will be committed to extinction by 2050, and well over a million species will already be extinct by then.
-Coastal cities around the world will experience more floods.
-By 2040 the average summer will be hotter than 2003, when a heat wave killed thousands of people in Europe.
-There will be catastrophic wildfires and water shortages in Europe and the Mediterranean area.
-In China, shifting monsoons will bring widespread drought, food shortages.
-India will see decreases in wheat and rice production and large scale die-offs of forests.
-Poorer countries, especially Africa, will have food shortages. Most of S. America will have corn shortages. World food prices will soar during lean years.
-Some Peruvian glaciers will shrink 40-60% by 2050, while others (including one that supplies Lima’s water) will be completely gone.
-Widespread conflicts seem likely.
-Water supplies in California may decline by a third to three quarters, while water supplies for Oregon and Washington may decline 20 to 70%.
-Flooding, and fires will increase in many parts of the world
-Sea level could rise 5 meters (16.4 feet) by 2100 even if it gets no hotter than this.
-Greenland may have no ice by around 2150, forcing half of humanity to move to higher ground.
-Two feedbacks: The earth’s largest carbon sink, the oceans, will begin absorbing much less of the excess CO2, and phytoplankton will no longer remove billions of tons of CO2 from circulation per year.


And here is what scientists predict for 2 - 3 degrees above current temperature, or 2.7 - 3.7 degrees above preindustrial levels. You have to go back 3 million years to find a time when the world was this hot. The world could get this hot as early as 2050 if we do nothing to stop it.

-The last time the world was this hot, beech trees grew in Antarctica, and Northern Greenland had pines and other conifers. El Nino patterns occurred every year. Sea level was 25 meters (49 feet) higher than now. And yet CO2 levels were only 360 to 400 ppm (we are currently around 386 ppm).
-El Nino could again happen every year. This will cause extreme drought in Indonesia and Australia and more rain for the South American West Coast. The 1912 El Nino caused storms in the North Atlantic, floods in China, drought in the Amazon, crop failures in Australia, famine in North Africa and India (no monsoon). The effect could be even stronger than 1912.
-Australia will be much hotter than now, with more fires and drought and agricultural collapse in the south.
-Snow caps in the Alps will all but disappear.
-Heat waves like those in the summer of 2003 will become the norm for Europe.
-More droughts and fires in parts of every continent.
-The Mediterranean will begin to turn into a desert as the Sahara jumps the sea.
-Monsoons will become more variable, flooding more some years, not raining enough other years, both affecting crops.
-Parts of Africa will get more rains and floods, other parts less water and more droughts. Malaria and dengue fever will move to higher altitudes and latitudes.
-The Indus, which waters the fields of Pakistan, will be dry for months of the year. Other rivers fed by Himalayan glaciers and supplying water to China, India, and other countries will begin to dry out.
-Hurricanes will probably be stronger, with Category 6 storms occurring.
-New Orleans may already be abandoned.
-New York City will face flooding: 100 year floods will happen roughly every 20 years by the 2050s and every 4 years by the 2080s.
-In England, 150 year floods could happen every 7 to 8 years by the 2080s.
-On the East coast, ocean levels could rise a meter, and coastal erosion could average 3 meters per year.
-There will be perennial drought and famine in much of southern Africa. Botswana will be entirely covered by shifting sand dunes by 2070, and no longer able to support human life.
-Yields of rice, wheat, and corn will decline in temperate regions and see crippling declines in tropical regions. More crops will grow closer to the poles, but the IPCC estimates there will be a net deficit with a 2.5 degree further rise.
-The Arctic will have an 80 to 100 percent reduction in sea ice.
-Many scientists predict a 3 degree rise will push us over the tipping point, if 2 degrees hasn’t already done so.
-A feedback loop will turn the Amazon into an arid savannah as early as 2027, which could raise temperatures one degree more, meaning 3 - 4 degrees hotter than now.
-Still another feedback is that vegetation and soils could release CO2 instead of absorbing it, adding an additional 90 - 250 ppm by 2100, which would cause the temperature to rise another 0.6 to 1.5 degrees C.
-Taking the previous two feedbacks together, 3 degrees could lead to 4.5 - 5.5 degrees higher than now, or 5.3 – 6.3 degrees C above preindustrial levels.
-The planet’s basic life support systems may begin to break down.
-Corals will bleach annually and will be nearly gone.
-The climate of 40 to 85% of the earth will shift towards the poles, too quickly for many species to migrate.
-The climate of 10 to 50% of the earth will be gone completely, no longer existing anywhere on earth.
-A third to a half of all species in existence today will be extinct by 2050.

So does this mean we are doomed? I think if the feedbacks occurred, billions of people would probably suffer and die, but I don't know if the human species will die off completely. That depends partly on what we do and partly on how the various feedbacks play out.

Two Degrees - Is It Possible?

The article at the link below talks about Obama trying to get countries at the G8 meeting to commit to reduce GHG emissions.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/31823389/ns/world_news-europe/

He was not successful, but a couple of agreements were made:

“The Group of Eight nations — Britain, Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Russia and the United States — agreed at their summit in this central Italian town to a goal of cutting the world's greenhouse gas emissions in half by 2050, and emissions from their countries by 80 percent by then to help get there.”

“The rich and emerging nations also together declared for the first time that average global temperatures should not rise higher than 2 degrees Celsius above those of preindustrial times. But the leaders made no commitments to do anything in the near term, say by 2020, to reach that goal.”

Why is 2 degrees Celsius important?

“That's the point at which the Earth's climate system would fall into perilous instability, according to the United Nations' chief panel on climate change.”

In this posting I will try to answer a question I had when reading the above article: Will cutting the world’s GHG emissions 50% by 2050, yet not doing anything significant before 2020, prevent global temperatures from rising more than 2 degrees Celsius above preindustrial levels? My gut said probably not, but I wanted to see if I could get an idea based on the current science.

I first did my own rough analysis of the data, based on charts from the U.S. government’s report “Global Climate Change Impacts in the United States”, which you can find here:
http://www.globalchange.gov/publications/reports/scientific-assessments/us-impacts

I came to the conclusion that if we don’t do much before 2020, the best case scenario is that we will reach 500 to 550 ppm CO2 equivalent before leveling off, some time around 2100, and the temperature will reach around 2.5 to 3 degrees C above preindustrial levels. This assumes no feedback mechanisms kick in before then, although we know that some of them (especially the albedo feedback) have already begun, so it’s probably worse than that. But since this was a very rough estimate that I made by extending lines on graphs, I don’t know how accurate it is.

So let’s see what the IPCC says. A recent article (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/william-s-becker/grading-a-climate-bill-pa_b_240312.html) says, “The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) suggested that industrial economies would have to reduce emissions 25-40 percent below 1990 levels by 2020 to keep warming to 2 degrees.” It even says that reducing emissions this much only gives us a 50-50 chance of keeping warming to 2 degrees. If that is correct, then doing less than a 25-40% reduction by 2020 would be extremely foolish. And yet the Waxman-Markey bill the House just passed only aims to reduce emissions 3.6% below 1990 levels by 2020. Doing so little by then, as we and the world as a whole are currently planning, seems to guarantee that we will go above 2 degrees warming.

The article doesn't have references for these figures, but I found a web page that explains in detail where these they come from (various places in the 2007 IPCC reports): http://www.holmeshummel.net/2C-Target-Range.htm.

The scary thing is that the IPCC is often too cautious with their predictions, and their data is always a few years out of date. Some of my earlier postings on this blog contain specific examples, but one very relevant example is that by 2007, emissions had risen about half a gigaton (roughly 6%) higher than even the very worst scenario from the 2007 IPCC reports predicted!

And I discovered something else. A quote I found in a document coming from the Bali meetings shows that the 25-40% range for industrialized countries assumes that developing countries will reduce their emissions at the same time: "The ranges would be significantly higher for Annex I Parties if they were the result of analysis assuming that emission reductions were to be undertaken exclusively by Annex I Parties." As you may know, developing nations have so far refused to do anything at all until developed nations make significant reductions. See the third paragraph of this document: http://unfccc.int/files/meetings/cop_13/application/pdf/awg_work_p.pdf.

Now let’s see what an environmental group says. There is a report called “Climate Code Red”, put out by Friends of the Earth Australia in 2008, which you can find here:

http://itsgettinghotinhere.files.wordpress.com/2008/02/climatecodered_1.pdf

On page 5 it lists some global temperature numbers:

Global temperatures have already risen about 0.8 degrees C above preindustrial levels.
Another 0.6 degrees C will occur due to “thermal inertia”, even if no more GHG are released.
The albedo feedback, which is already happening, will add another 0.3 degrees C.

So we are guaranteed to go 1.7 degrees C above preindustrial levels, even if we stopped all emissions immediately. Of course that is impossible, so what is the best we can do? The same report says that another 0.4 degrees C will be added to the system by 2030 if emissions remain the same (as 2007 levels, I assume). If we continue current trends, emissions won’t stay the same, but will rise 60% by then. Since nobody is committing to do anything significant by 2020, that means the world as a whole would have to cut their emissions 60% below the “business as usual” levels in the 10 year period from 2020 to 2030 to keep the rise to 0.4 degrees C. The developing countries are demanding that the developed countries act first, so they probably will do nothing for at least the first 10 years. I don’t think the developed countries will reduce their emissions 60% in 10 years, much less reduce them enough to make up for the developing world. So I’m almost certain that more than 0.4 degrees C will be added to the system by 2030. So that means that temperatures will eventually reach 2.1 degrees C above preindustrial levels even if all the industrialized nations make a superhuman effort to reduce their emissions after 2020. In other words, we are already pretty much committed to pushing the climate into “perlious instability”. And these numbers still only take one of the many feedbacks (Albedo) into account, so it almost surely will be worse than this.

And that’s not all. There is a “global dimming” effect caused by the particles and water vapor that come from the same sources as greenhouse gases. This has been “masking” about half of the warming effects of greenhouse gases. When emissions are reduced, the particles and vapors will leave the atmosphere quickly, while CO2 will not. So as we reduce emissions, the global dimming effect will quickly disappear. This is expected to add at least an additional 1 degree C of warming (0.8 degrees from what exists now plus the minimum future increase of 0.4 degrees). In other words, when you take global dimming into account, the best case scenario is more than 3 degrees C above preindustrial levels, and that still ignores all the known feedbacks except one.

So it looks like we are probably headed for at least 3 degrees above preindustrial levels, or 2.2 degrees above current levels. My next blog will list some of the things that scientists predict might happen if warming reaches 2 degrees C and 3 degrees C above current levels.

Wednesday, June 17, 2009

Impacts of Global Warming Report

Here’s an article about a report the US government just released on the impacts of global warming on the US.

http://www.truthout.org/061709O#comment-60496

You can find the full report and a summary here:

http://www.globalchange.gov/publications/reports/scientific-assessments/us-impacts

I’ve only begun to read the full report, but I’m almost sure it will not convey the real impacts on our lives. For example, it will probably mention that droughts will be more common in the Southwest, and hopefully it will go a step further and say something about reduced food output and water rationing. But will they talk about the worldwide famine that will occur because of the mega-droughts in the US, Australia, and other places, the shifting monsoon patterns, and because the glaciers that supply most of India and China will melt? I would be very surprised. Will they talk about the cannibalism that will occur when there is nothing else left to eat? That is the kind of thing we need to get through to people because otherwise they won’t take action (as we have seen).

In fact, I just searched the full report for “famine”, “starvation”, and “starve”, and there were no matches. There were matches for “food”, though. Here are the examples that had to do with human food:

"In an increasingly interdependent world, U.S. vulnerability to climate change is linked to the fates of other nations. For example, conflicts or mass migrations of people resulting from food scarcity and other resource limits, health impacts, or environmental stresses in other parts of the world could threaten U.S. national security. It is thus difficult to fully evaluate the impacts of climate change on the United States without considering the consequences of climate change elsewhere. However, such analysis is beyond the scope of this report."

"Climate change will increase productivity in certain crops and regions and reduce productivity in others (see for example Midwest and Great Plains regions)."

"However, under higher heat-trapping gas emissions scenarios, the projected climate changes are likely to increasingly challenge U.S. capacity to as efficiently produce food, feed, fuel,and livestock products."

"Climate change will affect society through impacts on the necessities and comforts of life: water, energy, housing, transportation, food, natural ecosystems, and health."

The way they put things is pretty dry and abstract, and it does not convey the extent of the changes. For example, how much will crop yields increase and decrease and which crops? Since the places where the vast majority of our food is produced will turn into desert or endure mega-droughts, I’m fairly certain that total food production will go down quite a bit relatively early and go down drastically later, but they don’t even give the impression that it will go down. This report, like others I’ve seen, also doesn’t say how the changes will actually affect people. There is a big difference between food prices going up a little and mass starvation, but if they only say there will be “impacts” or “changes” it doesn’t mean much, especially to most people. If you notice, the worst thing they say about food in our country is that efficiency will be challenged. They do briefly mention the possibility of food scarcity in other countries and say that might affect our "security". But what about how the cost of food goes up everywhere when it is scarce? And when our ability to produce our own food is severely curtailed, where will we get enough food when there is also a food scarcity in other countries? The obvious answer is we won't, and some of us will go hungry, even starve.

It’s great that the information is not being completely censored any more. But wording global warming impacts in a way that makes them seem pretty harmless is still a form of censorship.

Addendum 9/13/2009: After reading a lot more of the report, I have to admit that in many ways it is an excellent report. I really learned a lot. I still have issues with the way threats are downplayed, but it would probably have a fairly big impact on anyone who read the report. Unfortunately, judging by the climate bill the House passed, most of them didn’t bother to read it. That is disgraceful.

Monday, May 25, 2009

China, the US, and Climate Change

Here is an article about behind the scenes meetings between the U.S. and China, aimed at coming to an agreement to partner to solve the global warming problem. One person said they might even come up with something by this fall. The fact that the two largest emitters of greenhouse gases, who seemed to be playing "chicken" with each other during the Bush administration are now possibly on the verge of cooperating is a huge change for the better. James Hansen said we needed to start making big changes this year, or it would be too late to prevent a global cataclysm. It looks like there is still a chance we can pull it off if these talks succeed. We will have to see what the agreement is, and what actually gets done, and then only time will tell if it will be enough.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/may/18/secret-us-china-emissions-talks

Addendum 9/13/2001: Unfortunately, the climate bill the House passed this year has very anemic reduction target of 3.6% by 2020, about a tenth of what the IPCC said is needed. It also has a provision that would remove the EPA’s authority to regulate greenhouse gasses. Apparently the fossil fuel industry didn’t like the idea of the executive branch making larger cuts than the easily-controlled Congress. If this bill passes as is, it would be a disaster. Despite all the science and the pleadings from climate scientists like James Hansen, Congress seems determined to sacrifice our future in exchange for more corporate profits for their corporate donors. So much for an agreement with China. If the administration manages to get a good agreement, it would be meaningless without the authority to reduce greenhouse gases.

Friday, May 22, 2009

New Predictions

I saw one "good" piece of news recently. Some think our coal reserves may be much smaller than estimated before, which means the total amount of CO2 we will be able to emit may be smaller than forecast. They were even saying that the IPCC should lower their worst case global warming predictions. The reason this doesn't comfort me much is that if the worst case predictions came true, it would be absolutely horrible, and we have plenty of coal for that to happen. Also, things have turned out much worse than their worst-case predictions so far, so they need to revise them the other direction. It probably won't matter if we have less coal than we thought. We still have way more than enough to trigger feedbacks that will ruin the world for humans and most other species.

Today there was another piece of bad news. If you've read and/or seen "Six Degrees" yet, you know that even 1 or 2 more degrees will be really bad for us, and 6 degrees higher will be almost unimaginable. Now scientists at MIT predict that it will rise another 5 degrees (9 degrees F) by 2100 if current trends continue. If we implement an aggressive worldwide climate change policy, then it will "only" go up a little more than 2 degrees, still very scary. So most likely it will end up somewhere between those two numbers. But there is still much uncertainty, especially in the area of what use humans will do about the situation.

http://www.usatoday.com/tech/science/environment/2009-05-20-global-warming_N.htm

Friday, May 1, 2009

CO2 must be slashed more

"If the world is going to limit global warming to just a few degrees, it has to slash carbon dioxide pollution much more than now being discussed, two new science studies say."

http://dsc.discovery.com/news/2009/04/29/emissions-cut-warming.html

This is a good article overall, and pretty alarming. However, the person who wrote it doesn't seem to understand what he's reporting on, based on this quote: "World average temperatures going higher than that may be dangerous, some scientists say." Some scientists? How about the vast majority of climate scientists? MAY be dangerous? What an understatement! Calling it an understatement is an understatement!

It's very difficult for people to put this problem into perspective. The U.N. estimated that 300,000 people are dying every year because of the effects of global warming. That is NOW, with less than one degree C of warming so far. So global warming is already much more than "dangerous". Just one degree more, and there will be many more deaths because of famine and disease and severe weather. To want to limit temperature rise to 2 degrees is like saying it is perfectly acceptable to cause the deaths of millions of people, maybe even billions. And since we don't know when the big feedbacks will begin, it could even lead to the extinction of the human species. I wish people who report on this subject would learn more about it and then really tell it like it is, in a language that non-scientists would understand. And I wish the politicians would understand how many people they are killing RIGHT NOW with their policies and how many more will die in the future because they failed to take action.

Sunday, February 22, 2009

Worse than Predicted

When I first read the 2007 IPCC reports, as scary as they were, I was confused by how they seemed to downplay a lot of the threats. I knew that because of pressure from certain countries (U.S., China, Saudi Arabia were named in one article) they reduced the certainty level of some of their predictions. But I had been reading about studies that made things seem quite a bit worse than what was in the IPCC summaries. For example, the IPCC report said oceans would not rise much at all by 2100, but I was reading things that made it seem at least possible that they would rise much more by then. I read later that it takes a few years for new information to make it into those reports, so the reason was partly that they were a few years out of date. They also did not take feedback (or things like the lubricating effects of water at the bottom of the ice) into account in their models for melting ice. Not good when the IPCC reports are what governments are supposed to base their policies on. But they didn’t know how to quantify those things, so it’s understandable they didn’t want to include them in their models. The problem is that it made it easier for politicians to think they could delay action.

Periodically, since I started reading global warming and climate change news articles, an article would appear saying that some aspect of the problem was progressing faster than scientists expected. In 2007 I read so many articles like this that I suspected that some sort of feedback was already happening. In early 2008 I read that James Hansen had said the albedo feedback was already happening. Other scientists reported that the oceans might not be absorbing as much CO2 as they used to, another feedback effect. Forest fires were increasing because of global warming, which is another feedback. Most disturbingly, there were reports from Russia and Alaska that melting permafrost was already releasing methane and CO2, and even that some of the methane frozen at the bottom of the shallow ocean near Russia was being released. This was the most dangerous type of feedback that I had heard about, so I was not happy to hear that it might already be happening, even on a relatively small scale.

The article below talks about some of these things. It’s nice to hear someone from the IPCC finally admitting they were so far off. But we can’t wait for the next IPCC report, which comes out in 2014. Keep the pressure on our governments to solve this problem before it is too late.

http://www.truthout.org/021609M#comment-40896

Addendum 2/28/2009: Here is another story about both poles melting faster than expected. "There's some people who fear that this is the first signs of an incipient collapse of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet.... If the West Antarctica sheet collapses, then we're looking at a sea level rise of between 1 meter and 1.5 meters (3 feet, 4 inches to nearly 5 feet)."

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/29386865/

It's not just that things are warming faster than predicted. The IPCC is now saying that the earth won't have to warm up as much as thought in order to cause "serious consequences". For example, "increases in drought, heat waves and floods are projected in many regions and would have adverse impacts, including increased water stress, wildfire frequency and flood risks."

Addendum 3/15/2009: Here is yet another article where IPCC scientists are saying that their latest (2007) report underestimated the global warming threat. That report predicted the oceans would rise 7 to 23 inches by 2100. The new “best estimate” is 3.25 feet or about 1.7 times the old highest estimate, and that is IF we manage to reduce GHG emissions dramatically. The new highest estimate is 190 centimeters, or about 6 feet 3 inches. Even the old estimates would have been “enough to wipe out several small island nations and wreak havoc for tens of millions living in low-lying deltas”. A sea level rise of 1-2 meters would be “an absolute catastrophe” for China. But it would also be devastating to almost every coastal area, and especially for low-lying places like New Orleans, Bangladesh, The Netherlands, and so on:

http://dsc.discovery.com/news/2009/03/10/climate-sea-level.html

Addendum 8/21/2009: Here is another article (from 7/24/09) that talks about how global warming is worse than scientists thought, specifically in regards to the poles:

http://www.newsweek.com/id/208164

Almost as scary as the science in the article are most of the comments that I saw posted for it. It is amazing how confused so many people are about the science. Actually, that is not amazing, what is amazing is how passionately they defend their ignorant beliefs. The fossil fuels industry, in collaboration with conservatives, have done an amazing job confusing people.

Extinction in the News

Here are some recent articles on (mass) extinction and global warming. Mass extinction is what we should be trying to avoid at all costs, of course. Even if you only care about humans, our population would at best shrink dramatically (i.e. the vast majority of us would die) in a mass extinction, and at worst we would cease to exist entirely too.

Mass Extinctions May Follow One-Two Punch
http://dsc.discovery.com/news/2009/02/17/mass-extinction-theory.html

Study Sees Mass Extinctions via Warming
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/3897120/

Penguins Showing Strain Under Climate Change
http://dsc.discovery.com/news/2009/02/13/magellanic-penguins.html

Friday, February 13, 2009

The Best News

I think this is the best news I've heard since I started following news on global warming. "United on climate change: Obama's Chinese revolution"

http://www.truthout.org/020909N

Friday, February 6, 2009

More on What Could Happen (and What Is Happening)

In my last post I focused on the perils part of the U.S. would face with a one degree Centigrad rise in global temperature. Steven Chu, the new U.S. Energy Secretary painted a similar picture a couple of days ago:

"I don't think the American public has gripped in its gut what could happen," he said. "We're looking at a scenario where there's no more agriculture in California." And, he added, "I don't actually see how they can keep their cities going" either.

Here is the complete article:
http://www.truthout.org/020509EA#comment-38241

I am very glad that Obama appointed someone who is a real scientist and who can comprehend what is happening. I just hope it isn't too late.

I also mentioned that places like Australia would be experiencing droughts at the same time, and in fact they already are experiencing the worst drought in 117 years:
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/25617864/

Another article I read recently (which I couldn't find just now) said the Australian government acknowledged the drought was due to global warming and that it will only get worse. And China is also experiencing a drought right now that is so bad they declared an emergency. http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/d99e77fc-f38b-11dd-9c4b-0000779fd2ac.html

Just in: China raised the emergency from level 2 to level 1, their highest level of threat:
http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2009-02/06/content_10773460.htm

Korea is in a drought too right now:
http://joongangdaily.joins.com/article/view.asp?aid=2900712

And the Arctic continues to warm:
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/29038734/

This is just a hint of what will be happening in the coming years. Chu said California may not be producing crops by the end of this century, but I think it could happen earlier than that. I base this mostly on the fact that scientists continue to be surprised at how the effects of global warming are happening sooner and with more severity than they predict. Let's hope I'm wrong.

Addendum 2/28/09: Speaking of California and droughts, we are in our third year of a pretty bad drought, and even though we've gotten lots of rain and snow over the past couple of weeks, the federal government announced recently that it plans to cut off water from thousands of California farms for at least two weeks, starting tomorrow. The San Joaquin valley alone is expected to lose 1.15 billion dollars in wages, as 40,000 jobs are lost because of the drought. State residents will be asked to cut water use by 20%, and there will be mandatory rationing in some places. Here is the full article:

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/29302902/

I mentioned in an earlier post that California grows most of this country's fruits and vegetables, but the above article has specific examples at the bottom, such as 93% of the broccoli, 98% of the carrots, 86% of the garlic, 94% of the tomatoes, 99% of the almonds and walnuts, 95% of the apricots, 90% of the strawberries, and 100% of the olives. This is just a partial list, and it means prices for all these things will go up.

And remember, this is only a 3 year drought. During each succeeding year of drought, water becomes more scarce. Unless we invent and implement a way to remove massive amounts of CO2 from the atmosphere right away (an impossible task, really), global warming will continue to get worse for many years, regardless of what else we do. This means we will have more severe and longer lasting droughts over the next few decades. Farmers will suffer great economic hardships and many will go out of business. They and people whose jobs depend on them will be unemployed, and if it goes on long enough, they will have to migrate. But where will they go?

If we would have started cutting our GHG emissions years ago, when we first knew about the problem, we could have avoided this. Now it is becoming a fight for our very existence. Yet most people in power still think in terms of how much reducing GHG will hurt business or how much of the GDP it will cost. That is supremely stupid, because global warming is already going to hurt business and reduce our GDP way more than reducing GHG output would have, and if we delay much longer, there will be no GDP at all. I wish people would put things like this into perspective.

Wednesday, January 28, 2009

What Could Happen?

The best summary of what global warming could bring that I have seen is in the book “Six Degrees” and the National Geographic DVD of the same name. The author of the book (Mark Lynas) compiled the information from many scientific papers to get an idea of what changes we can expect if the average global temperature increases from 1 degree to 6 degrees Centigrade above the current temperature. I encourage everyone who is even slightly curious about the future to read the book and watch the DVD. The book goes into more detail and has a lot of information that the DVD does not have, but the DVD is more compelling and has some information that didn’t make it into the book.

Even the DVD doesn’t convey what actually living in such a world would be like. Without this knowledge, it is difficult to put the problem into perspective. Knowing that rising sea levels will force millions to relocate is not the same as the experience of losing your home, property, and neighborhood and having to find a new place to live and a way to make a living at the same time that millions of others are doing the same thing. I want to try to convey this kind of thing, even though I know I can only hint at the experience.

I want to focus first on one of the things that scientists think will happen with a one degree C temperature increase, partly because I don’t think we will avoid that much increase at this point, partly because few people understand what such a seemingly small increase could mean. Many scientists think that the Western part of the United States will be like it was during the Medieval Warm Period (around 800-1300 AD), the last time the temperature was that warm. I will focus on this region, because it is where I live, and I have paid special attention to predictions about this area. Scientists can see from tree rings and from trees that died when the water in lakes and river beds rose again that drought was the norm in the West during this period. In fact, the droughts were so severe and long that they call them mega-droughts.

Nowadays when a severe drought goes into its third year in California, we have to start rationing water so that we don’t run out. That means lawns don’t get watered, swimming pools and hot tubs don’t get filled, cars don’t get washed as often, showers are shorter, toilets are not flushed with each use, and so on. Since California has been a state, severe droughts have never lasted more than a few years. Three or four years is the longest I can remember experiencing. But during the Medieval Warm Period, droughts lasted as long as 50 or 60 years with no break. In a three year drought, you can still use more water than comes down from the sky, because the first year or two there is a surplus from the previous year, and the last year you can hope that it will rain and snow more in the coming winter. But when a drought lasts much longer than that, you only get what comes down each year, which is not much during a drought. When that happens for years in a row, California will not be able to grow the crops it is famous for, because there will not even be enough water to support the population, much less crops. People would have to move to other locations where water is more plentiful, and the people who stay would lead a very different life.

The Great Plains, our nation’s “breadbasket” could be even drier than California. During the Medieval Warm Period that part of the United States was a desert. I don’t mean that figuratively – it was literally made of sand dunes, and you can still find sand under the thin topsoil. This area included Texas, Oklahoma, Kansas, Colorado, Wyoming, N. Dakota, S. Dakota, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba. Obviously you can’t grow wheat or corn or soy in a desert. So grain and soy production will go down dramatically, and so will meat production. Every type of food will be scarce and expensive. (Even without global warming, fish are supposed to be extremely scarce in a few years, mainly because of over-fishing, and California grows most of our other vegetables and fruits, so that covers most of what we eat.)

Of course, the United States could import most of our food, but only if there is enough to import, and only if we could afford it. Canada should be able to produce more food at that stage of global warming, so we might buy a lot of our food from there. But Mexico and Central America will be suffering mega-droughts just like our West. (In fact, the Maya civilization ended during the Medieval Warm period, likely because of the long droughts they suffered.) Australia, another major food producer, will also be suffering drought conditions most of the time, as will many parts of Africa. And all over the world, people who depend on mountain glaciers for water will begin to suffer severe water shortages. Those glaciers have already shrunk dramatically, but it will get much worse. That means many other countries, including China and India, will not be able to produce nearly enough food for their own people. The recent food shortages that caused riots in several countries is nothing compared to the shortages we will see then. The dust bowl caused a lot of suffering when it occurred, and anyone who has read “The Grapes of Wrath” has gotten a taste of those times. But that is nothing compared to what will happen with a one degree temperature rise. Back then people moved from the drought-stricken states to California, but if California is in the middle of a mega-drought, people will be moving away from there too. Where will all those people go? And where will their food come from? Will Canada have to build a wall to keep out illegal American immigrants?

It is impossible to adequately describe or imagine what life will really be like then. But we can get some hints by looking at the past. There are some ruins in New Mexico where the most advanced civilization north of Mexico was located, and they either abandoned their buildings and migrated or died out during the mega-droughts of the Medieval Warm Period. On the top of their largest buildings are human bones with human teeth marks on them and signs that they were killed. Maybe people from other tribes killed and ate them, or maybe their own civilization broke up into competing factions. In Egypt there was at least one drought that went on for so long that people resorted to eating their own children. They must have already eaten all the other animals and edible plants at that point. Try to imagine what level of suffering would lead someone to eat their own children. Any sane person would want to avoid such a fate for himself, for his children, and for others. So why are we not doing what we need to do to avoid it? I can only conclude that people still don’t understand the threat of global warming.

We are much more advanced technologically than those older civilizations. But if there is such a severe, worldwide food shortage, at the very least many millions of people will starve to death in the poorer and less advanced countries. I think it will also throw our financial systems into complete chaos. The Pentagon did a study and said that the mass migrations will increase the likelihood of wars and conflict when these types of things begin to happen.

Water shortages caused by droughts and melting glaciers are not the only things that will happen with an increase in global temperatures of only one degree Centigrade. According to “Six Degrees”, here are other things that are predicted:

The Arctic ocean (North-West Passage) will be open (water instead of ice) half of the year.
Permafrost will melt even faster than now, releasing more CO2 and methane.
Tens of thousands of homes in the Bay of Bengal will be flooded.
Hurricanes will occur in the South Atlantic (off South America).
Storm intensity will increase, including cyclones (hurricanes).
England will be growing things like grapes that normally do not grow there.
The lands experiencing severe drought will increase from 3% to 30% of the planet.
Species will go extinct at an even faster rate than now.
Most of the coral will experience bleaching and eventually die.
Tuvalu, Kiribati, the Marshall Islands, Tokelau, and the Maldives will sink under water.

I think it is now too late to avoid this. I read about a year ago that there is another 0.6 degree C rise already “in the pipeline”, meaning it would occur even if we immediately and completely stopped producing excess green house gases (GHG). Plus the albedo feedback means another 0.3 degree rise is inevitable. And there may be another full degree that will happen as we stop putting particulate matter into the atmosphere when we finally do close down the coal plants. But we can survive this much. We should not give up, because things could get much, much worse than this. We need to reduce GHG emissions as much and as soon as possible and at the same time remove as much CO2 from the atmosphere as possible. Here is an article where scientists are finally speaking up about this subject:
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/28874983/

The article below, about the same study, sounds even more ominous. They are saying that the effects of global warming, however bad they get, will last about 1000 years after we bring our emissions down:
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=99888903

"The Long Thaw" by David Archer, a leading climate scientist, says the effects will last much longer than 1000 years after we severely reduce our emissions. The worst effects might last 100 to 1000 years, but CO2 levels won't fully return to preindustrial levels for hundreds of thousands of years.

Friday, January 23, 2009

Why this blog?

I've been sending emails about global warming and climate change to friends for a while now. Some of them suggested I start a blog to reach more people. This blog is meant primarily for people who already think global warming is real, although anyone is welcome to read it. I just don’t want to spend a lot of time trying to prove what the vast majority of climate scientists agree on. The fact that so many climate scientists agree should be sufficient for anyone who respects science and truth to want to find out more, at the very least. I want to start from there.

I think global warming is by far the most important topic for the human race at this time. While most people now realize it is happening, very few realize how bad it could get or how quickly we need to act. You can see this in the polls, where several other issues are always ranked as more important. You can see it in the way politicians talk about the issue, often referring to it, if they refer to it at all as a subset of energy independence (an insignificant subject in comparison). Most of all, you can see it in the inaction and counter-productive action at all levels, but especially the national level in most countries.Most people think global warming is similar to acid rain or the depletion of the ozone layer, or they think that greenhouse gases are just another form of pollution. But this is very different. Its quality is different, but it is also much more serious and much more urgent. It is not easy to explain why the situation is so urgent, and it is not easy to imagine what living in a world where global warming has gotten out of control would be like. I think that is what is needed the most right now, so that is where I will start. I will focus on the urgency in this post, which will also convey something about the unique quality of global warming, and begin to cover what could happen in the next.

By the way, if you are wondering why I’m using the term global warming instead of climate change, it is because climate change itself is not necessarily a threat. The climate changes all the time, and as long as the changes stay within a certain range, that is not a problem. It is the increase in global average temperature that will cause devastating climate changes. Climate science is the more general topic, but global warming is the problem.When you are steering a large ship, you can't wait until the last minute to turn. You have to begin the turn quite a while before you want to be headed in the new direction, and the turn will be wide and gradual. The faster the ship is moving, and the bigger it is, the more this is true. Carbon dioxide in the atmosphere is like a gigantic ship that has been accelerating for many decades. Only recently have we begun to notice the effects of the excess carbon dioxide (CO2) we have been putting into the atmosphere for so long. Once the level of CO2 stops rising and begins to fall, it will take hundreds of thousands of years for it to get completely back to pre-industrial levels naturally. Temperatures would also fall slowly. According to several models, it could take anywhere from 1,000 to more than 10,000 years for the temperature to get half way back to the preindustrial average, and to fully return to the preindustrial temperature range would take hundreds of thousands of years. (See “The Long Thaw”, by David Archer if you want to learn more about this.)It also takes quite a while for the effects of the CO2 we are releasing to be fully felt. I've read that it takes 50 to 100 years before most of the effects of CO2 emissions are felt. That is one reason we have to reduce our greenhouse gas output long before we see any major effects. But we will only be able to gradually reduce our output, probably over several decades at best. That means things are guaranteed to continue to get worse for many decades, unless we begin to actively remove massive amounts from the atmosphere (and we don’t know how to do that).There is an even more compelling reason why we must change our ways quickly: feedback. In the past, feedback has caused climate changes as huge as the difference between the current climate and that of an ice age in as little as 5 to 20 years. Just imagine living through a change like that. This out of control feedback is what we need to avoid at all costs. Once it starts, we won't be able to stop it, and we will have to adapt to the new climate. But there is a chance we won't be able to adjust, and the human species (along with most other species) will die out completely. Our planet has experienced several mass extinctions before, some of which probably were caused by the release of greenhouse gases, at least as one major factor. Regardless of the causes, the climate changed too quickly for most life to adapt, and anyone who values life wouldn’t want that to happen again, much less be the cause of it. And nobody would want to live (or die) through it.When you combine the very slow response time with the very fast feedback, you can understand why I am so worried. We have to reverse course many years before we reach the “tipping point” where that uncontrollable feedback starts, or else it will be too late. Instead, we are still increasing emissions at an alarming rate. From what I’ve read, I think we are very close to the point where it will be too late to stop runaway feedback. Unfortunately, we won’t know for sure until it is way too late to stop it. And the consequences are so bad that we should minimize the chances of this occurring as much as we possibly can. But we are doing the opposite.

One other very important point that most people do not really understand is that we will not get a second chance. If we mess this up, we mess it up essentially for good – for many times longer than human civilization has existed. Why would any sane person want to take chances with that?When might this point of no return come? Although many scientists say time is running out, nobody knows exactly how long we have. This uncertainty leads some to a false sense of security. They think that since we don't know for sure, that means it's not as bad as scientists say. But they ignore the fact that uncertainty always goes both ways. In other words, it is as likely that we have already run out of time as it is that we can take our time. And the pattern I keep seeing is that new data often proves things are worse than the scientific consensus. Since the stakes are so high, shouldn't we play it on the safe side and act as if we knew we had very little time? We know that it won’t destroy the world if we bring the level of CO2 in the atmosphere down, even all the way to preindustrial levels. It has been lower than it is now for all of human existence and for hundreds of millions of years before that. So we have nothing to lose by fighting global warming, and everything to lose by promoting it. There is simply no question what we should do, if we value life.But what if it is already too late? Does that mean we should give up since we are doomed anyway? No, because anything we can do to slow the change down will give us and other species more time to adapt. But also, we don’t know, so it makes no sense to give up now. We should do all we can while we still can. At this point we should act as if it is very late but not too late, because even if there was only a small chance we could save the world, we should try. Wouldn’t you try to save your baby as long as there was even the slightest chance you could? And isn’t that what we are talking about on a personal level? Your children, or the children you know will be stuck with whatever world we leave them. So what are you going to do?